Plumbers putty vs silicone sink drain It's not a primary drain seal strategy. Plumbing and Piping - Plumbers putty or gasket that came with sink strainer? - I am installing a new sink. In most videos I have seen that plumber putty is applied form inside of the sink and nothing else. 100% silicone caulk is recommend. Press around the flange to ensure a watertight seal. 1014 35th St. Easy Application. Don’t just think about the immediate application — though ease of use and application are certainly important — but the product’s composition, brand reputation, and performance characteristics. However, a plumber I spoke to said that the silicone will lose its seal and stiffen up No, you do not need to use plumber’s putty on a sink drain with a rubber gasket, as the gasket itself is sufficient to seal without putty. Plumber’s Putty vs. February 15, 2024. I was taught jackjegs use silicone and plumbers use putty. I’m assuming this will be a nice little home for food debris and everything gross to grow. Blog Home-Previous Post-Plumbers Putty and Silicone Putty: Benefits and Applications. No, plumbers putty is not required for a sink drain. As you've seen, silicone is not the best option for sealing drain flanges. It should ooze out as you tighten the drain in place. Silicone caulk is a waterproof sealant that You make a ring with the putty that gets compressed between the sink and the drain body as you tighten the nut. Plumber’s Putty is also incredibly easy to use and provides a strong seal that will last for a long time. Press the drain assembly into place in the drain opening. However IF installed correctly, Neither putty or silicon are needed. In general, you can use plumbers putty to: Install a kitchen faucet or kitchen sink strainer ; Install a bathroom faucet or drain ; Install a tub faucet or popup drain ; Install a shower drain on a shower pan or shower base ; While plumbers putty is a common way to create a waterproof I Tested The Best Plumbers Putty For Sink Drain Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below. You wont get a leak from underneath if you don't use plumber's putty of silicone or even that rubber gasket, those just allow the sink to hold water. What kind of sealer should be used between the strainer and the tub? I would use plumber's putty under the strainer, but noticed [Oatey's plumber's putty][2] says DO NOT USE ON PLASTIC (ABS, PVC). (Shower base can flex if not using a mortar base if manufacturer instructions says is not required) Putty on tub drains (easy removal) Silicone or foam gaskets on 1. If you’re out of plumber’s putty and need an urgent replacement, terrarium putty can do the trick. With Plumber putty, you can create a watertight seal between the base of a kitchen or bathroom faucet and the [] 2. Plumber’s Putty Review. I'm able to fit my fingernail between the sink surface and the drain flange in this area. Plumber’s putty comes in either oil or water based. 2b. They’re both great for sealing various plumbing About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Test new features NFL Sunday Ticket Press Copyright Plumber's putty is an oil-based plumbing sealant used to seal areas that are not under pressure. Most of what I read says to use plumbers putty around the bottom of the sink strainer between the strainer and sink. #debate #plumbersputty #silicone #versus #plumber #helpful #rab Do you need a plumber’s putty on the tub drain? Answer: It’s good to apply putty on damp surfaces. It works just like regular plumbers putty and works much better than silicone. More posts you may like This article takes a look at two common tools—duct sealant and plumber’s putty—to help you learn more about these useful products. I install multiple sinks a day with no putty or silicon, Non of my shit leaks. also in between the bottom of the sink and the I used silicon only on the last 2 sink drains I replaced However, I am here to learn, and would like to hear more from both sides on silicone vs non-staining putty. Use putty or silicone, do not use the rubber unless you want to constantly clean sink smeg because the drain will sit to proud and leave a moat of water. Silicone works, but if you see a pice sticking out and give it a pull, there's a good chance you will pull out all of the silicone. Silicone Caulk. Someone has to say it. Get them correctly centered and flip the gasket around from how it comes in the package. But each of them works adequately in different ways. It is quite pliable and has a texture similar to silly putty. Why? Well, you probably use boiling water and reasonably cold water in your sink, whether you are washing dishes, fetching water, or rinsing vegetables. Application Surface: Plumbers Putty is suitable for non-porous surfaces such as porcelain, stainless steel, and certain plastics. Silicone caulking; If the sink drain assembly comes with a foam or rubber gasket, use that WE NEED YOUR HELP WITH THIS DEBATE! Please let us know in the comments which you use and why. The rubber seals, the silicone, they never work right. Another alternative to plumber’s putty is silicone caulk. Silicone tends to stay hardened in certain areas of Plumbers use plumbers putty and silicone sealant to prevent leaking, finish around sinks and tubs, faucets, and drains. I prefer silicone over putty as that’s what I’ve been used to for 18 years and know how to work with it. Either is acceptable for fixing a drain. However, it is important to ensure that the rubber gasket is the appropriate size for your specific garbage disposal unit and sink drain. Reactions: GReynolds929. Disassemble the drain. Also why do we even need to seal the top part of the drain with anything when the bottom part has a rubber washer that is pressed against the bottom If you’re looking for a good alternative to plumbers putty, silicone is the best option. I guess a better question is, should I use plumbers tape between the drain and drain shoe? I know I should use the putty on the edge of the drain but someone told me to use plumbers tape on the This gasket is placed between the flange and the sink drain, creating a secure seal. Bathrooms can easily experience breakdowns or problems like any other part of your home. So, unless your granite guy is hooking up the plumbing, you don't have anything to worry about. 600+ bought in past month. Published: January 14, 2022. Unfortunately, my sink manufacturer's instructions are pretty pathetic and don't specify. Can you use Play-Doh as plumber’s putty? It’s not a great idea to use play-doh as a plumber’s putty. It is a much stronger binding agent, meaning it has the strength to hold The primary considerations when deciding whether to purchase Plumbers Putty or silicone sealant for your sink drain depends on what you need it for and whether it’s a short- or long-term problem. Even then, it might be a gamble as to whether it’ll damage your sink, as some sinks feature a warning against I read people put some underneath the flange instead of plumbers Putty. Faucets on sinks and baths; Drains on sinks, bathtubs, and showers; Unexposed areas that require water sealing; When not to use plumber’s putty. He will have a good argument as to why it shouldn't be changed. The action of squeezing and working the putty with your hands will make it more and more pliable, so it’s easier to roll out a thin worm of the putty. There are four parts Install your sink drain bodies with Putty, Silicone and dope and you will never have a problem. Be sure to wait 24 hours before using your sink again after applying silicon, and do not use abrasives or harsh cleaners on the stone while waiting for that time frame This means that you can use it to seal up tiny cracks and crevices all over your home. This is a must have for your plumbing arsenal - sealing tub drains, sink drains, pipes, so many things - works great, The gasket at the bottom at the nut is what prevents water from leaking out of the drain / sink On bathroom sinks I prefer to use putty at the sink/flange connection. Amer Toilets, Sinks, Showers, Dishwashers, Tubs and Garbage Disposals - Plumber's Putty vs Silicone Sealant - Hello, I am going to mount a ceramic vessel sink (white) on top of a vanity. This is not Putty on Basket strainers, lav drains, tub drains. With silicone caulk, you must apply an even amount either to the underside of the sink's drain assembly and to the sink immediately around the drain hole opening. Plumber’s putty and silicone sealant work differently. Seat the drain flange in the putty. Perhaps the most crucial difference between Plumber’s putty is commonly used for a variety of plumbing tasks, including sealing sink drains, attaching sink strainers, and setting toilet bases. Totally agree with putty, you may need to pull that drain 1/ or 2times a year if you have a wife, daughters and grandchildren that have long hair putty or rubber seals will be 1000 times better than silicon sealer, just saying because I just cleaned a sink again today, I love my wife’s , girls and grand daughters long hair, but I have to clean sink and tub drains at least 2x Redoing our bathroom and replaced the vanity. The great thing about silicone is that it only takes about 30 minutes to Plumber's Putty vs. 99. Plumber’s Putty. I feel like if the tub manufacturer says to use silicone then you will have no warranty on the tub if you use plumbers putty, but I would much rather not glue the drain onto the tub with silicone. Plumber’s putty and silicone sealants are both great products to use on your projects, but they each have their own set of uses and benefits. Just be sure the manufacturer of the tub allows it to be used. My sink strainers came with an almost foam like gasket for on top (for underneath there is a Then use some clear silicone but a good bead on it and reassemble. It’s flexible and made to seal plumbing gaps whenever necessary, enabling you to achieve a 100% water-proof seal with just a dab and smudge! 6 months ago while installing a new kitchen sink in my house, I accidently forgot to buy plumbers putty. However, my sink has a black rubber gasket installed from the outside of sink as can be seen here on top of the flange: Using plumber’s putty is very easy but to use it for a bathtub drain, you will first need to loosen the drain lip and start to warm up the putty in your hands. Plumbers First, start by removing the old putty from the drain flange and sink surface using a putty knife or your fingers. The basin can be used immediately without waiting for silicone to dry. Plumber's put I understand that usually people either use silicone or plumber’s putty, however there is a tiny valley between the drain flange and sink hole once I collected all of the overflow putty once tightened from underneath. $15. Should I use plumber’s putty or silicone on Plumbers putty and Silicone are both the most effective element for sink drains. Silicone Putty: Dos and Don’ts. marble, corian etc. Roll out a good size bead of plumbers putty around the sink flange lip. Plumber’s putty and silicone are often lumped together, and many people believe them to be interchangeable. Save Share Whether you decide to go with plumber’s silicone sealant or putty, it’s important to choose quality products designed to last. So, are you interested in learning more? Keep on reading then! What Is Plumber’s Putty? Plumbers putty is a sealing compound. Silicone Putty, on the other hand, adheres well to a wide range of surfaces including metal, glass, ceramics, and plastics. I can’t count how many times now I have been called to a bathroom leak under a sink now that they recommend silicone on the sink flange. Plumbers putty creates a watertight seal between the sink and drain components, preventing leaks and ensuring proper drainage. . Silicone will absolutely glue it so well that the only to get it off isto saw it in two. Because it doesn't set, which means the waste can be removed in future without a crowbar. Unlike some other sealants, plumber's putty remains soft over time and can be easily modified after its first application. I had to use a blade to cut the sealant underneath the sink, and there is a translucent weak sealant between the drain assembly and the sink where the drain assembly seals to the 900 Moldable Silicone Putty - White. The rubber gasket is the drain seal. Tighten the drain retaining nut. Zomar Member Plumbers use plumber's putty to seat the piece of the drain that is inside of the sink. PRODUCT IMAGE. Although silicone is usually more expensive than plumber’s putty, many people prefer it due to its versatility, ease of Obviously, you can use it. 3. The main characteristic that differentiates it from others is the fact that it will remain soft for a longer period of time after it is applied. I was taught jackjegs use silicone and Which is better, silicone or plumber’s putty? The answer to this question depends on the usage. 4 out of 5 stars. I am changing the drain only. On the other hand, the plumber’s dope comes with an applicator that is used to apply it on threaded pipes. There is a plumbers putty sold at Home Depot which is used when dealing with plastics, granite. Plumber's putty is more traditional while silicone caulking is a more modern product, but either one (in most cases) can get the job done. I’ve been doing it for years (master plumber out of Massachusetts) trying to grow better as a plumber The nut on the bottom side rotates. Typical domestic plumbing applications for plumber's putty are as a sealant between the base of a faucet and the surface of a sink, and between the rim of a basket drain and a sink. However, some modern sink designs come with pre-installed rubber gaskets, and silicone sealant is recommended instead. This section will explore ten significant differences between the two products. If you’re unsure, a professional plumber can help choose the best option. Silicone sealant or siliconized caulk is an adhesive and can't be Plumber’s Putty vs. Silicone. Is a plumber’s putty better than a gasket? Answer: Even though a plumber’s putty is a less expensive alternative, the rubber gasket is recommended. If you have silicone already installed around your sink basin, then you don’t need a plumber’s putty. It was discovered that with some poorly manufactured porcelain vanity sinks, either the top part of the sink where the drain was installed was irregular and not flat, or underneath the sink where the lower part of the drain was to be tightened could still have small voids between the cone washer was tighter at some areas and not others. our new sink came with conflicting instructions for installing the drain. I’m going to look in more detail about when to use each one. It's an easily workable, pliable, fixture-setting compound. Silicone sealant or siliconized caulk is an adhesive and can't be remolded or replaced after it has dried. This gasket is placed between the flange and the sink drain, creating a secure seal. Can you use a plumber’s putty on a washing machine? You can use a plumber’s putty in place of the rubber washer. No, you do not need to use plumber’s putty on a sink drain with a rubber gasket, as the gasket itself is sufficient to seal without putty. Rubber Gasket & O-Rings. As weeks go by, the stuff seems to absorb water and swells out. But what is it, exactly? And is silicone the same thing? Plumbers putty and silicone are both used to seal around plumbing fixtures, but they are not the same. On the rubber gasket on the bottom, some of them will leak where the rubber When installing a sink, plumbers putty is applied around the underside of the drain flange to create a tight seal, preventing water from leaking into the cabinet below. Use silicone between shower drain and pan, and faucets that bolt to marble, granite ect. As far as installing the drain, the putty vs silicone thing is a big debate. The whole focus is to watertight connections between drains and faucets, Install your sink drain bodies with Putty, Silicone and dope and you will never have a problem. Should I use silicone or plumbers putty for sink drain? You should use Plumbers putty vs silicone caulk: While plumber's putty is flexible without shrinking, silicone caulk is weather-resistant and incredibly durable. Silicone . While plumbers putty is more traditional, silicone caulk is a great modern alternative. Then clean it with turpentine or paint thinner. Reply reply kittehclaws • I noticed a small segment of the exposed plumber's putty around my kitchen sink drain had chipped off. Newmar used silicone caulk to seal the drain flange into to top side of the sink. Share: More. Silicone caulk isn't useful at all in plumbing. Plumbers putty is an easy-to-use product Putty on lav sinks (easy for removal). In the past when I have replaced the sink drain in the bathroom, I've always rolled some plumbers putty in a shape of a worm and put it around the opening of the sink drain hole. And unlike plumbers putty, silicone caulk will work on virtually any material. Share via: A yellowish sealant was placed between the rubber gasket and the sink. Scrape all the silicone off the sink and flange. Plumber's putty vs. Plumbers putty is designed for use with The putty will already keep the water out of the underside of the sink , if placed in properly. The reason why you shouldn’t use play-do instead of plumber’s putty is that plumber’s putty has greasy ingredients that resist water penetration. Where you need Either. Its water -resistant properties make it effective for use in wet areas such as kitchens and bathrooms, preventing leaks As a rule of thumb, use plumber’s putty for, you guessed it, plumbing. Many people use terrarium putty as a temporary substitute for plumber’s putty, especially in emergencies. Looking to create a water-tight seal around the sinks, drains, and faucets in your home? Plumber’s putty is probably the product you’re searching for. Plumber's putty remains soft and easy to remove, while The main difference between plumbers putty or silicone for sink drain is how easy the substances are to manipulate or remove. I used plumber's putty under the flange of my metal basket strainer in my stainless kitchen sink. There are several ways in which plumbers’ putty and silicone caulk differ. I suppose I disturbed it. They are specially designed to provide a durable and watertight seal for fittings made of plastic and pipe. A bathroom sink drain is commonly sealed with plumber’s putty. Silicone is for larger surface areas, to fill cracks and gaps, and for secure holding. Silicone, it usually better to let it cure for a bit before using it I tend to use putty for more common porcelain to drain sinks and silicone in more commercial settings. Its a non oil based plumbers putty. I am concerned that once I Funny that they used silicone and not plumbers putty ; but ; you should be able to remove without damage to the sink , if necessary a thin flexible For sink baskets, do you use silicone or plumbers putty? Everyone at my shop uses plumbers putty and I think it looks like shit. 1) Uses & Applications. Remove a piece of plumber's putty from its container and roll it between your hands to soften it. Plumber’s putty is Plumber’s putty is fine for sink fixtures, drains, or drain baskets. Had to order a non-overflow sink drain. You need to wrap the plumber’s putty around the area, and don’t leave gaps. Plumber's putty. Generally speaking, it is better to use a rubber gasket on a sink drain than a plumber putty. I’m going to dive deep into how to seal a bathroom sink drain properly in this article. As a rule of thumb, use plumber’s putty for, you guessed it, plumbing. Reply reply Top 1% Rank by size . Plumbers putty tends to harden immediately when it contacts the air; this makes it easier to apply and remove than silicone. I've tried pouring hot water, using a auger, and even a new toilet. Some sinks that you buy will come with strips of putty (6 pieces , 12" long) to place as a sealant between the sink and the countertop. PRODUCT NAME. They’re better for permanent fixes or high-pressure spots. Installing a sink drain can be made easier with plumber’s putty, offering superior sealing and durability for the job. Don't trust the manufactures gasket or the sink body. However, the two products are made differently. How To Seal A Bathroom Sink Drain. Use the We’ve done a test recently comparing plumbers putty vs silicone. I'm using a plumbers pack for the overflow and drain shoe (basically all pvc fittings glued together). b. 5. There are a couple of reasons why this is a great alternative you need to consider. For leaks that plumber’s putty can’t handle, go for silicone sealants, epoxy, or Teflon tape. Plumbers putty is very easy to manipulate into tight areas, and it’s also easier to remove. It’s important to remove all traces of the old putty to ensure a proper seal. 1. You do need to make sure that your plumber doesn't use the old standard plumber's putty though. Same is true when using plumber's putty. Galveston, Texas 77390. Any thoughts on what to best to use between the metal shower drain and abs shower pan to get the best seal? Plumbers putty for years has been the go-to product to use to create watertight seals between surfaces around faucets, sinks, and drains. Putty would just aid in cleaning around the drain flange. There are many conditions where plumbers putty could cause product failure and finished product staining, please refer to category #4 FAQs for these applications. However, silicone takes about 24 hours to dry completely. Should I re-install the basket assembly with silicone sealant? STOP!!MAKE SURE YOUR USING THE RIGHT PLUMBERS PUTTY! Regular plumbers putty or no stain plumbers putty? The wrong choice of plumbers sealant can cause st I am removing and replacing the sink drain in our master bath. Knowing the difference between silicone and plumber’s putty can drastically help if you’re looking to do some DIY projects at home. When you do basket strainers and sink drains do you use plumbers putty or silicone I’ve seen it done both ways. The drain that I have screws into the drain shoe using a drain removal tool. But in those videos that use plumber putty I have never seen anyone use a rubber gasket. It has the same consistency as plumber’s putty and much like plumber’s putty, it doesn’t harden but instead remains as a paste. The bottom rubber seal use that under your basin or you will have water leaking under your sink. I'm sure other people here who do it different then me would make the same statement. The next thing is to explore ways to make the seal watertight again, preventing water damage Some plumbers prefer plumber’s putty when installing sink drains, while others use silicone caulk because they have modern waterproof material. If the drain is rotating, that is likely the reason people are getting leaks using putty. I use exclusively silicone I feel it’s cleaner and stays intact longer can anyone prove me wrong. I read that plumber's putty can stain acrylic sinks, so I've seen silicone caulk recommended instead. The purpose of plumbers putty is to create a seal between two surfaces. In fact, you will love to use a silicone sealant instead of plumbers putty. Plumber’s putty is best for indoor, removable seals like sink drains, while silicone is ideal for permanent, watertight applications in high-moisture or outdoor environments. Plumber’s Putty is material used for watertight seals between surfaces in and around faucets, sinks, and drains, with the main aim of connecting pipes and countertops. 2. Sealing is an essential part of sink drain installation and maintenance because it keeps everything watertight. Plumber’s putty is commonly used for a variety of plumbing tasks, including sealing sink drains, attaching sink strainers, and setting toilet bases. Learn the differences, pros and cons of plumber’s putty and silicone caulk for sealing plumbing leaks. Silicone is to be used as caulking to seal edges like the skirt of a toilet or the edge of a drop in stainless sink. As it is not too fragile, it handles well in difficult places where putty won’t work well. 1,030. silicon. By now, you should have a clear idea of what plumbers putty vs silicone offer. Why use plumbers putty on sink drain? Plumbers putty is used on sink drains to seal pipe junctions, preventing water leaks and damage. Stainless steel prep sinks and other kitchen equipment Apart from that, it is better for large jobs where strength is preferable. ACTION. It won't crack, crumble, separate, harden or shrink. Z. Silicone: The Differences. However, some modern sink designs come with pre-installed rubber gaskets, and silicone sealant is Plumbing putty can be used in place of silicone to seal sink drains. They are interchangeable for some applications but not others. Silicone: A Comparison. Kitchens; Bathrooms; Brands; General Plumbing; Buying Guides; About; Should I Use Plumbers Putty or a Gasket When Installing a Sink Drain? Lonnie Thomas. Be sure to wait 24 hours before using your sink again after applying silicon, and do not use abrasives or harsh cleaners on the stone while waiting for that time frame I disassembled my kitchen sink today and the putty disintegrated. Plumber's putty is an easily workable, soft, pliable, fixture-setting compound. Silicone on lav sinks that are stone or some type of material where putty would leach through. Putty is more common and you can use the sink right away. I recently trimmed out over 100 apartments that used these style and what we did was use that gasket but apply silicone as well. Next, take a small amount of plumbers putty and roll it If you have to stop or prevent leaks around your faucet, sink, or tub drains, plumber's putty is the product you need. Untill I get an install that specifally forbids the use of putty to set a drain in cultured marble top, I'll stick with the putty. Both silicone and plumber’s putty are sealing compounds that will produce a watertight fit for sink strainers, the undersides of fittings, pop-up drains, and showers. Like the plumber's putty, some silicone caulk may squeeze out from between the drain body and the sink, which you must wipe off before it hardens. Menu Close Back to top . For a kitchen sink, I use plumbers caulk (putty) under the top flange of the tailpiece. The rubber ring on the under side of the sink that goes between the nut you hand tighten doesn't seem to be the best, and If your sink is leaking, look under the sink to see if water is leaking from the drain itself or from the pipes below. A plumber’s putty works best because it forms a watertight barrier. The sink is porcelain. 4. And you should have a better idea of their similarities. If you’re interested in DIY projects or a licensed master plumber who deals with regular sinks, drains, and other plumbing fixtures problems, a plumber’s putty is a handy thing to have in your tool arsenal. Both will work, and I'm not saying there is only one way to install a sink drain, but I use putty 100% of the time and I've never had any issues. On the contrary, Sink drains are a rather important part of the sink itself, especially if you want the sink to hold water. Doesn't do well with drain bottom (metal) to a plastic pipe connection. That goes for pop-ups, strainer baskets, shower drains depending on the style. I'm wanting to install this myself as the last 2 plumbers I called didn't even return my calls? Now I'm leaning towards using silicon caulk for the kitchen sink and wondered what your thoughts were and what brand and type you've recommend. Thus, plumber’s putty is often used to create a connection between a sink or tub drain and the drain pipe that carries wastewater away from the source, as this puts the seal under little to no pressure 3:18 kitchen sink - use a rubber washer on top instead of plumber's putty0:58 the washer does work on top0:19 groove for the collar0:48 the ring is tight0:43 Why is plumber's putty needed? In this episode of Repair and Replace, Vance shows how to properly use plumber's putty on a bathroom sink drain. Plumber’s putty won the day, but silicone can still work well if it’s all you have on hand. Silicone caulk is a waterproof sealant that On-site, it was silicone for everything, never used putty once. He cited his own personal experience with his trailer and that the putty may crack over time. That includes metals, ceramics, glass, stone, and even plastics. Apply The Putty: Spread the plumber’s putty around the surface, such as the drain of the sink. Plumber's putty is used (in the modern world) to keep gunk out of cracks and little else. Can you use silicone to seal a kitchen sink drain? Both plumbers putty vs caulk silicone are sealing compounds. Plumbers putty squishes perfectly until its 100% sealed every time I used putty between the drain flange and the sink, but it still seems to leak every so slightly. There is nothing wrong about this way and I'd never change, never had a problem so I stick to it. Unlike our new sink came with conflicting instructions for installing the drain. It’s easy to make if you have cat litter and some soil, and is waterproof to an extent. the box with the drain assembly has a diagram and instructions that do not include plumber's putty, yet the sink's installation instructions say to place putty in the notch around the drain and then place the FOAM strainer ring on top of the putty. Save more with Subscribe & Save. When properly used, the plumber’s putty will provide a watertight seal that will remain leak-free for many years. It is also commonly used when installing faucets to ensure a watertight connection between the faucet and the sink. A whitish translucent sealant was placed between the metal drain pipe and the hole in the sink. Find out how to use them properly and when to choose one over the other. Redo with plenty of plumbers putty between the drain flange and the sink. Supposedly I shouldn't use plumber's putty on plastic but I siliconed everything yesterday. Plumbers Putty vs. Plumbers putty is no different. The vanity top will be all wood with a good 1/2 dozen coats of poly to seal it. A popular choice of an alternative sealant to use plumber’s putty and plumbers putty are silicone-based sealants. When to use plumber’s putty. Although silicone and the plumbers putty are the most usable sealant in our construction journey, comparatively, silicone works better. However, even the strongest sealant doesn’t last forever. Just took out a stainless steel sink (the old thick kind) for my gf who was saving it for a new counter. If I remove the oozed-out stuff it keeps coming out (over time). If you’re looking for something that will withstand frequent weather fluctuation and high If you’ve ever done any plumbing work, you’ve probably used plumbers putty. It can hold anything tightly, whether a plumber putty can’t. Do You Use Plumbers Putty on Bathroom Sink? No, you should not use plumbers putty on a bathroom sink. Use the I'm installing a white acrylic sink, and I've read different things regarding the use of plumber's putty or silicone caulk to seat the drain in the sink. To mount the sink on top of the counter I am told I could To apply that thin rope of plumber’s putty, make a ring similar to the size of the drain pipe and press the putty against the pipe. Unlike other types of sealants, such as silicone or caulk, plumbers putty remains pliable and does not harden over time. Silicone is better on the pipes of those plumbing fixtures or for holding tiles in place. If you spot any prevent leaks, you need While both are effective at sealing joints, plumbers putty is more commonly used for sealing sinks, drains, and faucets, while silicone is commonly used for sealing showers, bathtubs, and other areas exposed to moisture. Anyone who insists on using putty or silicon on these, Is taking the "good enough" way out. Press the putty rope around the underside of the flange. Silicone makes a better connection for tub and sink drains and provides peace of mind👍. Just my opinion r/Plumbing • My toilet only drains if I add a pump of dish soap into the bowl. If you’re looking for a good alternative to plumbers putty, silicone is the best option. I never once saw a plumber use putty on site until I moved to Canada, which Canadian plumbers on the west coast used putty for lavs and kitchen sinks, silicone tubs and showers. So this putty is good for sinks, faucets, and drains. Using Plumber’s Putty And in some Plumber's putty is used to form a water tight seal between the sink and the faucet and between the sink and the drain. Both plumber's putty and silicone are sealing compounds designed to provide a water tight fit for pop up drains, sink strainers, undersides of fittings, showers and drains. I'm installing a white acrylic sink, and I've read different things regarding the use of plumber's putty or silicone caulk to seat the drain in the sink. Terrarium Putty . Here is what DIYers Should you use plumbers putty or silicone to seal bathtub drain or sink drain? In this guide, I go over the major differences between the two sealants and which one to choose for your bathtub or sink drain! When it comes to Yes, silicone sealants are safe for use on sink drains. The main difference between plumbers putty or silicone for sink drain is how easy the substances Plumber's Putty vs. Plumber's putty remains soft and easy to remove, while Summing Up Silicone vs. Silicone on shower drains connected to a base. That makes silicone putty better for waterproofing, even if it’s more difficult to work with. I use it: 2a. Using plumbers putty in these areas is where plumbers putty shines. Even with two men and all the correct tools the drain gets destroyed. I've been reading the pros and cons on reddit but there is no clear answer. If the sink drain gasket is old and cr Learn how to use Oatey Plumber's Putty. 99 $ 13. Threads don't agree! Reactions: RedStone and Gregsoldtruck79. The putty will not be used on the underside, as the ABS drain shoe comes with a thick rubber gasket. It won't hurt, but that's the way I was taught. Plumber's putty is commonly used under kitchen sinks to seal the area Let the sink dry. Should I use silicone or plumbers putty for sink drain? Home Blog Plumbers Putty and Silicone Putty: Benefits and Applications . Where home owners have used the The primary distinction between plumbers’ putty and silicone for sink drain is the ease with which the substances can be manipulated or removed. Oatey Plumber's Putty is an easy-to-mold setting compound designed for use with stainless steel sealing applications. They're both designed to create a watertight fit for drains, fittings, showers, sinks strainers, and more. So, it will be wise if you use silicone sealant. I have no idea what's going on. Plumber’s putty is very easy to work with in tight spaces, and it’s also very easy to remove. 75. I had been planning on using plumbers putty, but the assistant at HD suggested silicone due to the movement from the flexible plastic material. On the other hand, the play-doh is somewhat a mixture of flour paste and water. Re: Installing sink - putty or silicone? Author: PlumberManDan (IA) I use BOTH, If I use Silicone, I load it up, lightly press it in wipe the excess off the BOTTOM, PLace the gasket and the slip washer tighten the assy, let the excess that squeezes out on top stay RIGHT where it is, let it cure and then using a razor blade cut around the drain and pull off the excess. It works better for sealing drain bodies. While it may not be as crucial in a bathroom sink, Skip to content. All we use it plumbers putty for attaching pieces to fixtures. Over time, leaks and drips can become a problem. Mon – Sat: When it comes to sealing bathroom sinks, the debate between using silicone or plumber's putty is a never-ending one. So, don’t expose the seal to moisture until it has finished curing. As a result, silicone putty is superior for waterproofing, despite being more difficult to work with. The use of Rubber gaskets is a very effective way to stop leaks at joints on most fixtures and faucets. Remove the excess plumbers putty that squeezes out. Its water -resistant properties make it effective for use in wet areas such as kitchens and bathrooms, preventing leaks Silicone caulk and plumber’s putty are variations of sealing compounds that are commonly used to provide a watertight seal for sink drains, showers, faucets, and fittings. Menu. These are used by professionals, but by knowing Plumbers putty is a common solution for installing many types of metal plumbing fixtures. The instructions on a new sink say to apply plumber's putty around the drain before securing the drain assembly. It was running late by the time I had gotten to installing the drain and I wanted to finish the job that night instead of dragging it out to next morning and buying some putty. Plumbers putty worked the same but the rubber seals well with a light bead of silicone The net effect is that the putty just needs to be sandwiched between the flange and the sink to prevent water from leaking, either from an (intentionally) stopped sink into the overflow (bathroom) and thus down the drain, or from around the flange into the cabinet below when the flange acts as a reducer or on sinks without overflows (kitchen). silicone. After the sealant is dry turn to the sink drain water and check at any leaks. Plumbers Putty for Sink Drain, Wall Putty Hole Repair, Waterproof Sealant Mastic Putty, Quick Wall Mending Mud for Drain Connection-3pcs. RATING. Learn about the differences between silicone and plumber's putty to determine the best option for your installation needs. It seems there is a lot of advice on the internet saying don't use plumber's putty on cultured marble and certain other substances sinks are made of. 75 $ 15. It is typically used to seal the area around a drain where it meets the sink. Find out which one is easier, more durable, and more suitable for your needs. The plumber’s putty is perfect for flanges. For the drain and overflow, I'm torn between using traditional plumbers putty vs. $13. Plumber's Putty vs 100% Silicone for Kitchen Sink Install. What is the best sealant for PVC drain pipe? Generally, the easiest and most effective sealant for leaking plastic pipes is a liquid pipe compound as they can create air-tight seals around a leak. Silicone is often used as a sealant or caulking because it’s waterproof and can fill gaps effec Learn the differences and advantages of plumbers putty and silicone caulk for sealing sink drains and other plumbing fixtures. Plumber’s putty is a non-toxic sealant that provides excellent waterproofing solutions for sink drains. I’ll also compare which sealants should be used and how to use them properly. The gasket is placed between the joint, and as you tighten it, the rubber gasket gets squeezed to create a watertight seal that stops leaks at drains and faucets. You can use it to fill up gaps around windows, doors, sinks, toilets, tubs, showers, pipes, drains, and more. It's The top seal is just to hold water in sink when you have stopper in. However, a plumber I spoke to said that the silicone will lose its seal and stiffen up Here, we’re going to compare plumbers putty vs silicone so you can learn precisely what they offer and eventually pick the ideal option for your needs. Form the putty into a rope, 1/8 inch to 1/4 inch thick. Utility Nav About Careers Contact Us Where to Buy Plumber's putty vs. The most popular products for sealing kitchen sink drains are plumber’s putty and silicone sealant. Plumbers putty works, silicone works better because it’s more flexible and won’t crack out if he gets bumped It’s clear that both plumber’s putty and silicone have their uses in bathrooms, kitchens, and other areas around the home. Plumber's Mait. The previous owners used a good amount of silicone and what a nightmare to remove 20 years later. Apparently, it's the oil in the putty that stains, and I cannot find any putty which says it is non-staining. Plumber’s putty is moldable putty that seals plumbing components to avoid water leaks. You’ve just noticed water dropping from the seal around your sink drain. I just bought a new sink drain and they are Plumber’s Dope or Pipe Dope is a little bit different than the other items described. The main differences between plumber's putty and silicone caulk are that silicone is an adhesive, while plumber's putty is not. I was wondering if I should use plumbers tape on the drain, or is the putty enough? EDIT: Thank you for your responses. Today I went to tighten the drain underneath and the silicone hadn't set after 24hr. All was good until I found out it was plastic not metal. Plumber’s Putty Vs. That said, you can use plumber’s putty on stainless steel, providing it’s explicitly marked as safe for stainless steel. mgznpnh uypzfq atpfsqbe viyk sbpy hwkit aaii nafg ezxj fou

Plumbers putty vs silicone sink drain. 1) Uses & Applications.